Your 4-Step Fundraising Check-In (What to Do Every Quarter)

Let me tell you something I’ve seen too many times to count:

A church or nonprofit is running hard—events, outreach, food pantry, youth ministry, the whole nine yards. They know their work matters. But when it comes to fundraising?

It’s chaos.

Not because they don’t care.

Not because they don’t have faith.

But because nobody ever gave them a plan.

Here’s what I want you to know: fundraising doesn’t have to feel reactive, confusing, or last-minute. When you build in a rhythm—a quarterly check-in—it gives you a steady pulse. It builds trust with your people. And it gives you peace of mind, knowing you’re doing what works.

I’ve worked with churches that went from “we can’t afford to do this anymore” to “we’re fully funded and hiring staff.” This check-in rhythm was part of how we got them there.

Step 1: Review the Money (But Don’t Stop There)

Start with the numbers. Every 90 days, take 30 minutes and ask:

  • What came in?
  • From where?
  • Is it recurring or one-time?
  • Did we hit our fundraising goal for this quarter?

But don’t stop there.

Numbers without reflection are just noise.

Dig deeper:

  • Did any donors drop off? Why?
  • Did someone surprise you with a larger gift? Did you follow up?
  • Were there any gaps in funding for programs you expected to support?

Pro Tip: Create a simple quarterly giving dashboard. Don’t overcomplicate it. You just need:

Donor name | Gift amount | Gift type (one-time/recurring) | Source (event/email/etc.)

This kind of data lets you spot trends early—so you can respond with intention, not panic.

Step 2: Check Your Communications

Too often, I hear leaders say, “Well, we didn’t ask this month.”

That’s not the real issue. The real issue is: Did your people hear from you at all?

Ask yourself:

  • Did we share at least one story this quarter? Not a pitch. A story. Something real.
  • Did we say thank you? Not just “thanks,” but why their gift mattered.
  • Did we show the results their giving helped create?

People don’t give to silence. They give to transformation.

Pro Tip:

Use a simple rhythm:

Month 1: Story → “Here’s the impact.”

Month 2: Gratitude → “Here’s how you helped.”

Month 3: Call to Action → “Help us reach this goal.”

If you’re stuck, start with this question:

“What’s one moment from the last 90 days that made you proud?”

Turn that into a short post or email. That’s your story.

Step 3: Reset the Goal (Yes, Again)

You wouldn’t drive without a destination.

So why fundraise without a quarterly goal?

Pick one focused goal for the next 90 days. Not five. Not vague dreams. One.

Examples:

  • Add 5 new monthly donors.
  • Raise $3,000 for youth summer programs.
  • Cover the cost of food distribution for 100 families.

The point here is focus. The most common mistake I see? Leaders trying to fundraise for everything at once. That leads to mixed messages and exhausted donors.

Pro Tip:

Tie your goal to a tangible outcome.

Don’t just say, “Help us raise $5,000.”

Say: “Help us send 20 students to camp this summer.”

Specificity creates clarity. Clarity builds trust. Trust fuels giving.

Step 4: Choose the One Next Step

This is where most leaders freeze.

They get overwhelmed. They think they need a 12-month master plan with spreadsheets, branding, and backup singers.

You don’t.

  • You just need one next step.
  • Write the donor update you’ve been putting off.
  • Schedule a lunch with a top supporter.
  • Launch a mini campaign for a single program.
  • Re-send the booking link to that warm lead.

Pro Tip:

At the end of every check-in, ask:

“What’s the one thing I can do this week to move this forward?”

Write it down. Put it on your calendar. Do it.

Because movement beats perfection. Always.

Want Help With This?

If you’re trying to figure this out alone—stop.

We built a free **Starter Kit** that shows you how to raise consistent funding without hiring a fundraiser, throwing another gala, or chasing grants that don’t align.

This is real help for real churches and nonprofits—especially Black-led ones—doing powerful work with limited time and capacity.

Download the Starter Kit here

Let me close with this:

Quarterly check-ins aren’t just about raising more money.

They’re about stewardship. They’re about rhythm. They’re about building the kind of stability that lets you breathe again—and lead from a place of *vision* instead of survival.

You’re not behind. You’re building.

And you’re not building alone.

Let’s go.

Author

  • Paul Hosch is the Founder and CEO of Nonprofit Fundraising Management (NFM), a firm dedicated to helping religious institutions grow their financial capacity. With over two decades of experience and more than $50M raised, Paul has led fundraising efforts for organizations such as Verbum Dei Jesuit High School, USC’s Keck School of Medicine, and The Emory Fellowship. He holds a B.S. in Business from USC and is pursuing a master’s in Nonprofit Management at the University of San Francisco, with a thesis on fundraising in the Black Church. Paul also serves on the TACSC Board and is Chairman Emeritus at Santa Monica College. Outside of work, he enjoys art, vegan cooking, travel, reading, and proudly holds the title of “world’s greatest uncle."